Fergus, A Law Office
Contact Fergus, A Law Office, Today 866-256-5487
Finding Creative Solutions For Complex Problems

When does inspiration spill over into copyright infringement?

Many copyright infringement cases for musician's hinge on what exactly is infringement and what is not. At what point do songs go from having similarities to all out copyright infringement? If you were to ask many of the creative people behind the music, they would most likely say that the knowledge they have on writing music is based on what influenced them musically. While this does not mean these artists should only play a version of what inspires them, but how far away do they need to stray away from those influences to be safe from copyright infringement?

This begs the question, can new music be created without inspiration from music that came before? If it can, which seems to be the case, how much if at all can it sound like the original?

Is an internet trend proving copyright infringement?

A new trend on popular social media websites including YouTube, is users creating a mashup. A mashup is blending two songs together to create one new song. However, there have been times where a mashup has contained up to six songs all blended together where it is very difficult to know when it switches from one artist to the next. If these songs sound so similar as to not be recognizable in a mashup, shouldn't there be a copyright infringement case to be made?

Pursuing copyright violators

Many artists and those who own the rights to certain music do not seem to be allowing much wiggle room for the inspirational argument. Copyright infringement cases seem to be growing as more artists come across music that sounds eerily similar to their own. Just a few of the artists who have been sued for copyright infringement include Justin Bieber, Led Zeppelin, Ed Sheeran, Kanye West and Bruno Mars. This list can go on and on.

Infringement of musical property goes way back

Copyright infringement has even seen cases where just short sections of songs or the general feel of the composition elicits an accusation of infringement. The act of doing this sort of borrowing may have come from the top classical composers that ever lived, where it seemed common to all out copy or re-interpret older work to create new compositions.

Copyright violators have a knack of citing the influence of another artist or how much a certain piece of music inspired them. Regardless of the reason, if there has been an infringement on someone else's musical property, they may be subject to legal action for copyright infringement.

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
Email Us For A Response

Serious Help For Serious Legal Problems

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

  • American Bar Association | Defending Liberty | Pursuing Justice
  • AV | Martindale-hubbell | PeerReviewRated | for ethical standards and legal ability
  • Bar Register | Preeminent Lawyers | 2019 | Martindale-hubbell
  • Gray S. Fergus | 5/5.0 / Peer Rating | Heigh Ethical Standing
  • AV | Martindale-hubbell | Preeminent 2019
  • Lawyers | Of | Distinction | 2019
  • Bar Register
Icon Office Address

Fergus, A Law Office
535 Mission Street 14th Floor
San Francisco, CA 94105

Toll Free: 866-256-5487
Fax: 415-537-9038
San Francisco Office Location

Icon Phone Number
Back to Top